Ive gone on NG+3 so this is mostly just for my personal curiosity on what the general public thinks is the best for each. I Wont be including Soul of Rosaria, mainly because by the time you get it, you more than likely have better healing on hand already, so you might as well return it to her. Please spread this around as much as you are able, if you so wish. I would like to try and get as much feedback on this as i can.