As I said, I will now be repolling any previous ones which ended in a tie, after checking I found this was the first one to end in a tie. It is from March last year (2022) when the theme was Poison. I appreciate people will want to reread the stories before voting again as I'm not expecting people to remember them, so I hope these hyperlinks work, I will put them in the comments if they don't. Remember be objective but you can vote for yourself if you honestly believe it is the best.
Apples and Agony- PaganPrincess: https://www.reddit.com/r/hahaohno/comments/t5uno3/apples_and_agony_poison_submission/
The Wrong Planet: Afterlife- LadyWillaKoi: https://www.reddit.com/r/hahaohno/comments/tm2gz9/the_wrong_planet_afterlife_march_poison_story_2022/
Toxic- SarahGlover16: https://www.reddit.com/r/hahaohno/comments/ttar8j/toxic_my_poison_story/
Not sure if strictly necessary to state but if you are reading these having not read them before then LadyWillaKoi's was a sequel to a previous months, if you wish to read part 1 first (not counted in this submission) here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/hahaohno/comments/magd04/the_wrong_planet_march_2021_space/
Also after the month ended I wrote a part 2 to mine, also not counted as part of the submission but if you want to read that here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/hahaohno/comments/tu0icd/continuation_of_toxic_poison_story/
I can't set closing dates anymore so can announce this as closed (cannot ever physically close it) whenever I want. Maybe I'll give it a week and see, I can leave it until the end of the month but there are many I will be repolling and don't want too many open at once.
Your vote: The Wrong Planet: Afterlife- LadyWillaKoi