There does not seem to be a coherent argument for which is the best. And I figured as these seem to be the best ranger blades at the moment, we get a consensus on which blade performs best. If you have the math to show the reason for your choice, even better. I do get that each blade may be better in different situations but assume I will be using rogue against either a neutral sicarius or a sicarius against which I have its weakness (Fire Earth and light - *maybe wind; but not likely*)