Shoutout to /u/super_nerd92 for giving me the idea to do this awhile ago when he started doing his blind player comparisons without looking at the names. I thought it'd be interesting to see which QB stats align most with the general consensus on QBs, and through that, see which stats might be the best measure of QBs. Full disclosure, part of the reason I'm doing this was because I threw together a QB stat [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/7jmdyi/expected_points_contributed_a_new_and_hopefully/?utm_content=title&utm_medium=user&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=frontpage) and wanted to see how it compared to others, but I also think this is a fun exercise in general. With that being said, here goes, here are all the QBs and their stats in the last 10 years, minimum 50 games started(keep in mind that it's only looking at those 10 years, so for example Peyton Manning will be lower than usual because it'll weigh his Broncos' years more and miss out on most of his Colts years). Rank|Stat 1|Stat 2|Stat 3|Stat 4|Stat 5|Stat 6|Stat 7| --:|:--|:--|:--|:--|:--|:--|:--| 1|Aaron Rodgers|Tom Brady|Tom Brady|Drew Brees|Aaron Rodgers|Aaron Rodgers|Aaron Rodgers| 2|Tom Brady|Aaron Rodgers|Peyton Manning|Aaron Rodgers|Tom Brady|Peyton Manning|Drew Brees| 3|Drew Brees|Drew Brees|Russell Wilson|Tom Brady|Drew Brees|Drew Brees|Peyton Manning| 4|Russell Wilson|Peyton Manning|Ben Roethlisberger|Peyton Manning|Peyton Manning|Tom Brady|Tom Brady| 5|Peyton Manning|Philip Rivers|Aaron Rodgers|Andrew Luck|Tony Romo|Tony Romo|Andrew Luck| 6|Tony Romo|Tony Romo|Alex Smith|Kirk Cousins|Russell Wilson|Philip Rivers|Kirk Cousins| 7|Philip Rivers|Russell Wilson|Andrew Luck|Matthew Stafford|Philip Rivers|Russell Wilson|Cam Newton| 8|Kirk Cousins|Kirk Cousins|Drew Brees|Tony Romo|Kirk Cousins|Kirk Cousins|Tony Romo| 9|Ben Roethlisberger|Ben Roethlisberger|Matt Ryan|Russell Wilson|Ben Roethlisberger|Andrew Luck|Philip Rivers| 10|Matt Ryan|Matt Ryan|Joe Flacco|Philip Rivers|Matt Ryan|Cam Newton|Russell Wilson| 11|Alex Smith|Matt Schaub|Andy Dalton|Cam Newton|Andrew Luck|Andy Dalton|Matthew Stafford| 12|Matt Schaub|Andrew Luck|Tony Romo|Ben Roethlisberger|Cam Newton|Ben Roethlisberger|Ben Roethlisberger| 13|Andy Dalton|Andy Dalton|Cam Newton|Matt Ryan|Matt Schaub|Eli Manning|Andy Dalton| 14|Colin Kaepernick|Alex Smith|Matt Schaub|Matt Schaub|Andy Dalton|Matt Ryan|Matt Ryan| 15|Derek Carr|Eli Manning|Mark Sanchez|Derek Carr|Alex Smith|Jay Cutler|Eli Manning| 16|Matthew Stafford|Matthew Stafford|Eli Manning|Andy Dalton|Matthew Stafford|Matthew Stafford|Derek Carr| 17|Andrew Luck|Carson Palmer|Carson Palmer|Carson Palmer|Eli Manning|Derek Carr|Carson Palmer| 18|Eli Manning|Derek Carr|Jay Cutler|Alex Smith|Colin Kaepernick|Carson Palmer|Jay Cutler| 19|Carson Palmer|Colin Kaepernick|Philip Rivers|Colin Kaepernick|Derek Carr|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Blake Bortles| 20|Ryan Tannehill|Cam Newton|Colin Kaepernick|Eli Manning|Carson Palmer|Matt Schaub|Ryan Fitzpatrick| 21|Cam Newton|Kyle Orton|Ryan Tannehill|Blake Bortles|Kyle Orton|Alex Smith|Matt Schaub| 22|Jay Cutler|Jay Cutler|Matthew Stafford|Kyle Orton|Jay Cutler|Colin Kaepernick|Colin Kaepernick| 23|Sam Bradford|Joe Flacco|Derek Carr|Ryan Tannehill|Ryan Tannehill|Mark Sanchez|Ryan Tannehill| 24|Kyle Orton|Ryan Tannehill|Kyle Orton|Jay Cutler|Joe Flacco|Kyle Orton|Alex Smith| 25|Joe Flacco|Sam Bradford|Kirk Cousins|Sam Bradford|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Blake Bortles|Kyle Orton| 26|Jason Campbell|Jason Campbell|Matt Cassel|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Blake Bortles|Ryan Tannehill|Josh Freeman| 27|Blake Bortles|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Matt Hasselbeck|Joe Flacco|Sam Bradford|Joe Flacco|Joe Flacco| 28|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Josh Freeman|Sam Bradford|Josh Freeman|Jason Campbell|Josh Freeman|Mark Sanchez| 29|Matt Cassel|Blake Bortles|Ryan Fitzpatrick|Jason Campbell|Josh Freeman|Matt Cassel|Matt Cassel| 30|Josh Freeman|Matt Cassel|Josh Freeman|Chad Henne|Matt Cassel|Sam Bradford|Sam Bradford| 31|Matt Hasselbeck|Matt Hasselbeck|Jason Campbell|Matt Cassel|Matt Hasselbeck|Jason Campbell|Jason Campbell| 32|Chad Henne|Mark Sanchez|Blake Bortles|Matt Hasselbeck|Mark Sanchez|Matt Hasselbeck|Chad Henne| 33|Mark Sanchez|Chad Henne|Chad Henne|Mark Sanchez|Chad Henne|Chad Henne|Matt Hasselbeck| Which one do you think is the best?